Thermal versus membrane desalination

Two ways to separate salt from water: boil the water off, or push it through a membrane. Membranes won on energy, which is why almost all new capacity is reverse osmosis.

Thermal versus membrane desalinationTwo parallel routes from seawater to fresh water. The thermal route heats seawater so it flashes to vapour in a series of chambers at falling pressure, condensing to distillate, and uses roughly 10 to 25 kilowatt-hours per cubic metre equivalent. The membrane route pressurises seawater through reverse osmosis membranes with energy recovery, using roughly 3 to 4 kilowatt-hours per cubic metre. Both produce a concentrated brine that must be disposed of.Seawater~35 g/lHeatingthermal routeFlash chambersfalling pressureDistillate10–25 kWh/m³ equiv.Pressurisationmembrane routeRO membranesPermeate3–4 kWh/m³Brine disposalthe shared problem
Why thermal persists
Thermal plants tolerate poor feedwater that would foul membranes, and make sense where waste heat from power generation is free.
The theoretical floor
Separating salt from seawater cannot take less than about 1 kWh/m³ thermodynamically. Modern RO at 3 kWh/m³ is already within a factor of three of that limit.
Brine
Roughly twice the salinity of the feed, and often warmer. Discharge design determines whether it disperses or forms a dense layer on the seabed.

Text description

Two parallel routes from seawater to fresh water. The thermal route heats seawater so it flashes to vapour in a series of chambers at falling pressure, condensing to distillate, and uses roughly 10 to 25 kilowatt-hours per cubic metre equivalent. The membrane route pressurises seawater through reverse osmosis membranes with energy recovery, using roughly 3 to 4 kilowatt-hours per cubic metre. Both produce a concentrated brine that must be disposed of.